Deadlocked: Gloucester Twp. Teacher Negotiations Still at Impasse
Fact-finding is coming up in two months, but could an informal meeting before then bridge the contract settlement gap? Only if the school board and teachers union can actually agree to meet.
It’s become something of a routine by now. At every recent Gloucester Township school board meeting, a contingent of red-shirted teachers shows up. Usually someone talks about the stalled teacher contract negotiations, sometimes not.
But in truth, the board of education and the Gloucester Township Education Association (GTEA) teachers union are treading on unfamiliar ground. The two sides agree on very little, except this: No one can remember the last time negotiations took this long or progressed to this point.
“We have never been to this stage,” GTEA President Angel McDermott said at the Jan. 28 board meeting. “In my 16 years as president (and) my six years as negotiations chair before that, we have never reached this stage. This is new to all of us.”
The 600-plus teachers in the K-8 district’s 11 schools have worked without a formal contract since the last agreement expired on June 30, 2012. Negotiations are so stalled and mediation so mired that the school board and GTEA decided to proceed with fact-finding, a formal process where a mutually agreed upon fact-finder holds hearings and makes recommendations on a settlement.
But even that decision is caught up in disagreements. The school board says GTEA cancelled a planned Jan. 7 fact-finding meeting; GTEA says the school board didn’t allot enough time for a fact-finding meeting on Jan. 7 and it was prepared to meet more informally instead. With the meeting called off, the next available date is in late March.
And that’s just a very minor disagreement on a list of issues creating an impasse on the teacher contracts. As the school board and GTEA slog to find common ground, students have or will start to see the effects of the protracted negotiations as teachers begin job actions.
Teachers could begin upholding the letter of their employment agreement and refuse any extra work not required. That may mean no extended afterschool hours or no extra work to plan activities and trips.
The school board denied on Monday knowing whether job actions will occur, but a board member spoke out against it. While saying she has the utmost respect for Gloucester Township teachers, Linda Gilch said job actions only harm students.
“You’re not hurting us, you’re not hurting the board, you’re not hurting administrators by doing any type of job action—you’re hurting the children,” she said. “I understand you want a contract and I understand we need to come to a consensus. But you’re not taking anything away from us.”
A parent and teacher in another district, Debra Hines, countered that the board expects “250 percent” from its educators, who don’t like the job actions either.
“It’s crushing them to be lowered down to the level to treat (students) as minimally as possible,” she said. “If they start to give what they’re contractually supposed to give, and they pull back, it’s breaking their heart inside. They would prefer to have a contract and be treated with dignity and the respect they deserve for educating children.”
A ray of hope?
The impasse between the board and teachers shows little sign of cracking. Both sides stood resolute in laying the blame at the other’s feet, although they may meet again before the March fact-finding session.
“We would be willing to meet again to try to discuss it. But meeting also entails the parties compromising on some situations, and part of the difficulty we have is we haven’t been able to bridge that gap,” John Wade, school board solicitor, said.
“Unfortunately, we’re in a situation where we have 2-percent cap, we have restrictions on us now the likes of which we’ve never had before. So, we came to the table and said we have certain restrictions and we need to operate within those restrictions. You folks didn’t take that position.”
The school board didn’t approach its 2-percent cap in budget talks, McDermott retorted.
“Do you want to settle the contract for 2 percent?” Wade shot back. “I’m a little frustrated because we’re hearing this now. The reality is you’re not willing to settle for 2 percent. You’ve told us that.”
McDermott later said GTEA and the school board are “approximately 2 percent” apart on their demands for the contract. She also acknowledged there are unspecified school-board positions that the GTEA will not agree to.
“Yes, compromises need to be made, but we have to see where that will lie,” she said.
The next Gloucester Township Board of Education meeting is scheduled for Feb. 25 at 7 p.m. at Lewis Middle School. If recent history is any indication, the room will once again be filled with teachers wearing their signature red GTEA polo shirts.
Mel
6:52 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Hey Wade, the 2% cap was not meant to be a cap on teachers salaries but meant to force bloated and corrupt local boards to stop padding the budget in the administration side with waste like a personal F-150 truck that includes free maintenance for the unqualified Superintendent and made-up political patronage jobs for your friends on town council. How can you justify bringing in outside people to be principals with a large pay raise when you can't afford to pay teachers!
Cut the goddam waste in the administration before you start crying poor to the teachers! They are the reasons why you are here! Maybe if the motor pool didn't have to waste taxpayer money installing hunting equipment including a deer rack on the Super's truck we would have money to pay the teachers! How much taxpayer money is pissed away supporting Bilodeau's deer hunting hobby?
Cut the waste and do you job! The 2% cap exists to make you and the board do the HARD work such as saying no to your political friends. Our schools are no longer a patronage pit and cash cow to make you and your friends rich.
StopComplaining
8:58 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
A couple of years ago,the legislature passed health/pension reforms requiring public employees to begin paying for their health insurance via a percentage of their salary phased over four years. If rumors are true, this is the first year teachers are contributing under this new law. Although I don't have any idea what the issues are in the negoiations, I would quess that the teachers want their usual percentage increase, over 4,5% the last round, as well as extra money to cover their contributions to their benefits, It was not the intent of the new laws to continue to have taxpayers pay for their lavish insurance plans, (hospital, prescription,dental, and vision) while taxpayers pay 100% of their costs if they can even afford them. Teachers make a good salary for the ten months they work. Most of the GT taxpayer don't make between$50-$90K for ten months and get FREE benefits.
Head
9:23 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Mel, You make a couple of good points.
But buried in your rant is a statement that, for me, highlights the biggest underlying problem.
You wrote "Cut the...waste in the administration before you start crying poor to the teachers! They are the reasons why you are here!"
Both sides seem to forget that the whole idea of schools is to be focused on students.
Mel
9:30 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Head: Then let me clarify. The teachers are there to teach. They are the ones who are focused on the students. They are the ones who spend the time with the students. The administration's job is to support the teachers so the teachers can teach our children.
Pete Heinbaugh
10:12 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Mel,
Regarding Wade's 2% cap statement, I'm sure that he understands the difference between a 2% salary increase and a 2% tax cap. I think he's just being intentionally coy and insincere.
Paul J. DiBartolo
11:01 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
What's so surprising, Pete? He's a lawyer, isn't he?
SJ Birds Fan
9:03 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Another article where no details are provided.
Can we have an answer to 2 Simple questions -
What does the union want?
What has the district offered?
Ginger McCarty
12:56 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
I'm so sick of seeing those signs in car windows when I drop my child off at school. I work everyday without a contract and so do thousands of other parents. I'm sure both sides are to blame to a certain degree. Both sides need to grow up and stop demanding they get everything they want and find a compromise.
Bearsmom
9:47 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Bearsmom
The bus drives have no contract either.
Schu
10:11 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Pay the good teachers more and fire the lazy good old boys club teachers.
Paul J. DiBartolo
10:59 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
You and I both wish.
Ginger McCarty
10:17 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
The bus drivers have no contract because they made an agreement with the last superintendent to open their contracts and he gave them an extra year in return. So instead of their contracts ending in 2011 they ended in 2012 with the teachers. Which only serves to give the teachers more leverage because if the teachers decide to strike so will the bus drivers.
Paul J. DiBartolo
10:59 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Actually, if the teachers strike what need have we of bus drivers? Doesn't that save us some money in the long run?
Rob
10:19 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
It would be nice to know the sticking points in the negotiations. But the economy is stagnant and education already makes up a large portion of our already too high taxes. I am by no means an expert but I do have teacher friends collecting a pension in their mid fifties. You wont find that in the private sector. But then again a township that cant afford to come to an agreement with teachers shouldn't be spending 250, 000 dollars on a monster truck.
Hadenough
11:55 am on Thursday, January 31, 2013
The five educators charged in the sex scandal—teachers Jeffrey Logandro, 32, Nicholas Martinelli, 28, and Daniel Michielli, 27, and administrators Catherine DePaul, 55, and Jernee Kollock, 39—currently are suspended with pay.
Christine
1:00 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
FYI - These are not Gloucester Township teachers/administrators. The high school is its own district. Talk about a way to cut costs....
robert d
12:40 pm on Thursday, January 31, 2013
i peronally think teachers get paid fairly will consideing that they work 9 months a year, but thats not the point i want to make we have are spending a ton of money on a armor vehiclle where we could have used it here or hiring more police, an i know about th capital fund but there are ways around that.
Hadenough
1:13 pm on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Tell me Lilli - WHAT IS IMPORTANT! My opinion is that it is IMPORTANT for teachers to know their boundaries and NOT CROSS the line with their students. It is IMPORTANT that teachers do not ABUSE the AUTHORITY given to them. It is IMPORTANT that parents feel safe to send their kids to school, NO MATTER WHAT AGE! It is IMPORTANT that heads of Authority in a school district be held to a higher standard rather than the slime that was brought out and exposed. It is important to respect those teachers who really are in it to make a difference and RECOGNIZE those who are wolves in sheep’s clothing. As a resident of Camden County, I have a right to COMPLAIN that my tax money is STILL GOING TOWARDS the salaries of the teachers and administrators who corrupted the very fiber of what should be a safe haven for kids. Seriously, I think you need to prioritize !!!
Darren Gladden
1:43 pm on Thursday, January 31, 2013
I am clapping it is written like it came from da Heart
Sybil Evans
7:18 pm on Thursday, February 21, 2013
Your clapping because your buddy josh asked you to support his post. So like a good puppy you slapp your hands together. Don't forget to shake your pom poms.
robert d
1:37 pm on Thursday, January 31, 2013
as i said they could have used the money to pay the teachers or hire more police, do we really need a armor vehicle that is already provider for by he county or is gloucese twp that bad as camden is. nothing against the teachers but no one in pvt sector gets 2 months off with pay , but your job is hard an i realize it.
Concerned
10:46 am on Saturday, February 2, 2013
Teachers work 10 months. Teachers get paid for 10 months. 40 checks total during a 12 month period - 2 checks a month, September -June. The contracted year is September -June, the pay is September -June. Please get your facts straight before making wrong comparisons. Also, teachers are paid for 184 days, not vacations, like in the private sector. Teachers cannot take personal time for their own children's activities, as in the private sector. Finally, teachers cannot use the bathroom at will, as in the private sector. There is give and take in both. If the private sector is so envious of the teachers' jobs, then the private sector employees should have been teachers. Most would not have lasted because being a teacher takes a giving person, not one enraged with envy.
Joe
1:52 pm on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Isn't the fox watching the hen house? Check teachers benefits and sick time used. Thier benefits are better than Township employees who are so often criticized. And, it seems my kids has at least one teacher out sick every other day. So thier 9 month year plus every holiday plus thier own (teachers convention that they don't attend and go to Florida) isn't really that but they get full time pay. And, they get larger raises every year than Township employees. Why? Give them nothing, just like everyone else gets.
joy
8:22 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
So teachers shouldn't get 10 sick days/year? Never mind that they share a classroom of at least 20 students who share their germs every minute of every day. By the way, in GT, teachers get written up if they use more than 5 days by December. Oh and they cannot use sick days when their own kids are sick.
Teacher's Convention, holiday and summers are NOT PAID!
Do Township employees have the same degree/credentials/certifications/required professional development hours as GT teachers?
Concerned
11:05 am on Saturday, February 2, 2013
Along with my previous comment, I beseech you to walk through a school on a 90 degree day. Do private sector employees have air conditioning? Yes. Do teachers work without? Yes. TEACHERS work without air conditioning, but my guess is the board does not. Get a degree and teach. See how long you last.
mr
12:44 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013
Teachers don't get paid for holidays, conventions, or vacation time as private sector employees do. Teachers are not paid in the summer. they don' get paid when they have to stay home and take care of their own sick child. Plus teachers work 10 months, and are only paid during those 10 months.
Ginger McCarty
1:56 pm on Thursday, January 31, 2013
They don't get the summed off with pay. They are not allowed to collect unemployment either. It's written into their contracts. So some teachers do have to get summer jobs. So do the bus drivers. The teachers were getting their healthcare paid for in full. Because of the law they are not anymore and rightly so. Private sector people have to pay for their insurance so should teachers. What usually ends up being the issue is raises and how much they're going to pay in insurance. I'm sorry but in an economy like this with so many unemployed and just getting by, demanding a certain % raise every year doesn't sit well with the taxpayers. Whether that's fair or not its the way it is.
joy
8:16 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
Christie made sure that teachers are now paying for their insurance. The problem lies with the money that you are paying into schools are NOT being used for what it is intended. Teachers are getting punished for the low economy status but GT is so top-heavy. The administrators just settled their contract with a 2% increase.
stophating
10:37 am on Wednesday, February 6, 2013
joy - you should really take a look at the administration of other districts this size if you think GT is top heavy. you're just listening to the Christie nonsense. GT is far from top heavy and has had about 7 admin vacancies since the summer. also, with the new teacher evaluation systems coming down the line, districts will be looking to hire more administrators since they will have to do about 3x the number of observations each year.
Lauren Burgoon
1:59 pm on Thursday, January 31, 2013
No cursing on Patch. If your comment was deleted because of profanity, you're welcome to repost the PG-rated version.
Rob
2:22 pm on Thursday, January 31, 2013
Lilli, do you know what the sticking points are in the contracts? If you do could you please share them? My main concern is that the salaries should not be out of proportion with the private sector. I send my children to private school and from my personal experience I feel they are receiving a better education from teachers I know are making less money with less benefits. I am willing to pay out of pocket for a better education. It seems to me every time a contract is up for renewal it is more, more, more. I could only wish I had 2 to 3 months off a year and had the benefits we give our teachers. I hope that I am not coming off as anti-teacher but the compensation has to be realistic. Higher compensation does not equal better teachers.
joy
8:13 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
Rob, go ahead and get your teaching degree if you want 2-3 months off. Teachers are NOT paid in the summer.
Winston
12:57 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
It would be nice to know what the contract issues are so taxpayers/parents would be educated as to who to provide support during this impasse.
Sue N.
12:59 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
Before you put a teacher down, please remember these are the people who are spending 7 hours a day, 5 days a week with YOUR children. This is probably more time than some of you parents see your own children. These are the people who teach and keep your children safe, while you are out earning a living yourself. There are bad "seeds" in any profession, but their are LOTS and LOTS of teachers that go WAY above and beyond what are contract states because we truly LOVE what we do, so please give us the respect that we deserve. For all of you complaining that we only work 9 months out of the year, what is stopping you from getting your education degree?
Sue N.
12:59 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
"our contract" spelling correction
Bearsmom
12:59 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
The teachers having sex with students was BHP Regional. Nothing to do with GL Twp B.O.E. The high school teachers are without contracts also. No one gets free health benefits anymore. EVERYONE pays. Teachers and Bus drivers all have to get summer jobs if they want money in the summer time. Some bus drivers work 2- 3 jobs to make ends meat. They only get paid on average 13.00-14.00 dollars an hour. for 4-6.5 hours a day depending on run. Take out all the taxes and dues and so forth and a driver who makes say $800.00 gross a pay every two weeks only takes home about $450.00 to $500.00 in take home pay.
Christine
1:00 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
Why doesn't anyone address the issue of the separate school districts - Gloucester Twp. (K-8) and Black Horse Pike Regional (9-12). Why are we paying for two superintendents, countless assistants, and curriculum supervisors? The 2% budget cap could be adhered to by eliminating positions at the top (the people who make 6 figures) instead of nickle and diming the middle class teachers.
Darren Gladden
11:36 am on Saturday, February 2, 2013
WOW ....you make a good point now would you like to run for Mayor you will be better then Dave
mr
12:51 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013
Great question. Wasn't this idea shot down a few years ago?
Joe Kearney
7:33 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
Just a quick question How long have Gloucester Twp Public Schools been using John Wade as a Lawyer? What kinda money are we paying this guy? He seems to have a very strong hold on the School district, Maybe its time we gave another Law Firm in Gloucester Township a chance. Might save us some money and new thinking.
Mel
9:13 am on Saturday, February 2, 2013
At the BHPRSD meeting right after the sex scandal broke, someone pointed out to the audience that Ed Wade and his firm of Wade Long Wood and Kennedy are the third highest donors to Gloucester Township Democrats. 5 of the 9 GT school board members are "Democrat Hacks" as one angry parent described them at this meeting.
Do the math, do you think 5 hacks placed on the board are there to fire the underperforming attorney that funds their campaigns? Isn't the school board there to ensure our childrens education? Why are they giving jobs to the people who fund their and their friend's campaigns?
mr
12:49 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013
GT citizens and GT school parents need to start paying attention to all that goes on, start asking questions, and demanding honest answers. It is our children's education at stake.
joy
8:12 pm on Friday, February 1, 2013
GT teachers do not get paid on holidays and summers off. They have a 184-day contract...so divide their annual salary by the number of contracted days. If you are going to compare them to the private sector, take education (most of them have a master's degree or higher), certification (add more university credits to their master's degree. Most teachers have more than one certificate), professional development hours required by the state on top of the education requirements and years of experience. They DO NOT match salary (include benefits and insurance too) of anyone in the private sector with the same amount of qualifications.
Ask yourself this: Has your property tax gone down? You're still paying high property taxes that "go" to school expenditures. GT Teachers are on the same salary schedule less the amount that they are contributing to their health insurance. Where is that leftover money? The money already budgeted? The school board is sitting on it. Earning interest on it, oh, and possibly buying more things for the township that are not needed or hiring more administration, with higher pay.
Ask yourself this: Currently, the GT BOE does not have a Business Manager. Who used to be the business manager? The current interim superintendent. Who is doing the BM job? The current interim superintendent. Check the BOE finances and make sure that no one is double dipping.
Darren Gladden
11:48 am on Saturday, February 2, 2013
Are you saying there a BOAT LOAD of money being Stash in town by the LEADERSHIP I wonder if someone has it hidden in his stache .......Now everything makes since now I know why they got the APC to guard there money and make sure the people live in fear or just get so tried of all there SHADY ways and move out then that make the prices go down on the houses in town . So now they can make money with their 2,876,549,954 LLC companies can make there money .."REDLIGHT CAMS".Hey Peeps I been telling you about the SHADY land deals 2 years agO . Look the fat cats that run this Town are never in this town unless it's a Photo Op........Give me a break and wake up People and vote Dave and his Dream crew out . Then LET'S all go hunting for all the MONEY they are hidding in all THOSE funds .....Just care , I do
Sybil Evans
7:27 pm on Thursday, February 21, 2013
Darren ironic you would ask anyone to vote when your nickname is "Just Vote I Don't Gladden" inquiring minds want to know did you even vote when you were on the ballot? Rumor has it you only voted in 2 elections out of 48 public elections in Gloucester Township in the last 10 years. Your primary and your general elections. Seems you like telling others to vote, but you don't. Now thats the type leadership you bring to the table. Poor choices, poor attitude and even more poor voting record.
Rob
11:52 am on Saturday, February 2, 2013
Still nobody has said what the sticking points are in the negotiations. Surely someone here knows. Its difficult to form an educated opinion when the facts are not available.
Darren Gladden
12:03 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013
word Rob I think the towns wants to give a 2.0 rise and the teachers want like 3 -3.5
........Now rememeber the teachers are now paying for the health Ins and the Top Heavy ADD peeps are giving title jobs to there friends Rises of 2% to themselves , Now let's look at some MATH they make over 100,000 those creepy Top Heavy peeps .Now if you get a 2% raise on over 100,000 that a good chunk of change now if you give a teacher say at 50,000 a 2% raise NOW WHO ARE THE PIGS stealing the taxpayers money ....THE TOP HEAVY people ........The FAT Cats I say ........Pay the Teacher and start cutting back on some REAL WASTE THE FAT CATS pay
mr
12:54 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013
Heard Gt BOE wants to give 1.5 or 1.6 % increase to teachers.
Mel
12:25 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013
I cannot say how things are structered here, but in other towns teachers have the choice of collecting paychecks over 10 months or over 12 months. They are essentially salaried with a yearly salary, not a daily salary. Their checks are not reduced when there are no school days.
I agree I would like to know the details of the impasse. The article says it is more than just salary. What are the other points?
mr
12:58 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013
GT Teachers are given no option - they can only get paid over 10 months: Sept To Jun
Mel
1:53 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013
Maybe that is something that can be added to the current contract. They do it this way in other towns with the paid over 12 months so teachers can monthly budget for the year based soely on their teaching salary.
This brings up another point: what other best practices do other schools in the area do that we do not, and why don't we? It is that the GTEA and GT Board discussed them and decided against them, or is it that our board does not take the time to do so?
l Paine
8:12 am on Sunday, February 3, 2013
While the District was in a downward spiral for a few years now, the retirement of Seddon and the School Board's political agenda has thrown the downward spiral into hyper-speed. The Board moving their puppet Bilodeau into "Interim Superintendent" a man with no teaching experience and very little people skills, as evident by the mass exodus of some very good people in the district to administrative positions in other districts instead of working under Bilodeau and this board. Think about it how bad must it really be in our district for the Administrators who left to give up accumulated sick days, tenure and a district they are familiar with to just pick up and start over. The attempt recently of mass transfers of Principals in the middle of a school year (talk about a disruption to a building). Contract talks with Teachers and Support Staff that can be best described as a mess. A budget where money is moved around to different accounts every month. Why? Do they want to confuse the public by keep moving it until we lose track and give up? Remember the Board presented a Budget we voted on it, so was it real or was it just numbers and once passed they would spend it the way THEY wanted to? This Board and current Administration has a history of ignoring the opinion of parents, the public and even the employees and doing as they please. The time has come to replace this Board and Administration with people that will listen and respect our opinions.
Concerned
8:44 am on Sunday, February 3, 2013
Wish there was a "thumbs up -like" for this comment. Well said.
mr
11:59 am on Sunday, February 3, 2013
Kudos for putting it all out there
Schu
9:08 am on Sunday, February 3, 2013
This township is becoming a cesspool for corruption, hacks and patronage jobs.
mr
12:01 pm on Sunday, February 3, 2013
It's now up to the taxpaying citizens to make this situation change!
November is not too far off
l Paine
2:42 pm on Sunday, February 3, 2013
The Board's appointment of Bilodeau as "Interim Superintendent" speaks volumes of how out of touch they are and how political this district has become. They will tell anybody who listens the appointment of Bilodeau, a man with no classroom time and minimal people skills was made because they couldn't find any qualified people to fill the position after almost a one year search. REALLY! Maybe no qualified canidates willing to be the Board's puppet. Time to start cleaning house and getting new Board members and rid ourselves of political hacks like Collins, Carr and the rest of them and get people that will put children first. People need to keep going to the meetings and keeping the heat on the Board and Bilodeau, with tough questions and the demand for straight and truthful answers.
Christine
4:02 pm on Sunday, February 3, 2013
I'm pretty sure none of the current board members even have children in the Gloucester Twp school district anymore. As board president Linda Gilch said at the last meeting, any job action "isn't hurting us." Can't we find some people with a vested interested in the school to run for the board?
l Paine
5:06 pm on Sunday, February 3, 2013
It's that type of attitude by this Board and Administration that we are subjected to on a daily basis. An attitude of contempt directed at parents, the public and district employees. An attitude that they are better and smarter and we are not smart enough to ask questions or offer solutions.It's time tomake this Board and Administration uncomfortable by going to meetings, calling the Administration Building and asking questions and more importantly demanding answers. In the future vote in new Board members that put the children first.
Didjaknow
9:00 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
We do have to vote in new board members, but who ever runs but the incumbents? The classic move by this board is to run incumbents (and they usually run unopposed) as a "ticket" together. Then, a few months after the election, one will "retire". Know what happens then? THE CURRENT BOARD GETS TO APPOINT THEIR CHOICE FOR THE REMAINDER OF THE TERM. So, two years later, the "new" member runs as an incumbent of the "ticket"! Check into this, I think this has happened several times in the last 10 years!
Hadenough
10:42 am on Wednesday, February 6, 2013
Yep !!! You are correct! THAT HOW THESE SCHOOL DISTRICTS ROLL. IT UP TO THE PARENTS AND TAXPAYERS TO STAND UP AGAINST THE CORRUPTION.
l Paine
10:00 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
If we can't get people to run then the only thing to do is press this Board with tough questions at every meeting demand answers and hold this Board and accountable. Ask questions at meetings, call Administration building, ask questions if you see them shopping. Just keep asking questions and if don't want to answer get the Courier Post or TV news involved, maybe they will answer then.
AM
8:10 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013
Getting the Courier Post or TV involved is definitely the way to go. This information MUST become common knowledge for the parent/taxpayer.
stophating
10:42 am on Wednesday, February 6, 2013
The GT BOE is only interested in political gain. They hired Orlando Mercado as a supervisor and word on the street is that he's not even certified for the position. He has no K-12 experience and is politically connected like the board. The town needs to get involved, put up some real candidates for school board and tell this board to take a hike.
Paul J. DiBartolo
10:54 am on Wednesday, February 6, 2013
I have not looked into the Orlando Mercado aspect of this issue but have read enough questions and criticisms about the situation on the patch to know that there appears to be something up. So, I'm wondering why no one has raised this question during the public portion of the GT council meeting. What's up, people?
Darren Gladden
12:57 pm on Wednesday, February 6, 2013
don't you have a vocie also Paul , What's up Paul ..........
Paul J. DiBartolo
2:55 pm on Wednesday, February 6, 2013
Darren, why are you picking on me? I said I don't know the particulars on this one as well as the fact that I've had no problem standing up at council meeting and voicing my concerns. Were you sleeping when I did so?
Darren Gladden
9:30 pm on Thursday, February 7, 2013
I'm not picking on you ....
Chris
9:55 pm on Wednesday, February 6, 2013
The scariest part of all these comments is when someone has something to say about not supporting the teachers, the grammar in their comments shows that they themselves are writing on a pre-school level. Please stop calling it a "fact-finding" in every other union in the world it's called arbitration. Also, my report from the last board meeting showed that the board was obviously disinterested with the concerns of the teachers, ill-equipped to answer the "tough" questions of the parents who pay their salaries as well. So thank you for your contempt, have a nice day.
Paul J. DiBartolo
9:36 am on Thursday, February 7, 2013
Wow, your angst is showing...What are you trying to say about the grammar? Are you suggesting that we couldn't do it without the teachers? We're just not smart enough; is that your point? BTW, did you run your post through a punctuation checker because you missed a few? That's got me wondering at exactly which grade level you dropped out of the cycle.
A little advice, if you're going to make a point in a post about bad spelling, grammar, or punctuation, you do yourself a disservice when you don't double-check your own post and make sure it is error free. Just sayin'.
Chris
6:08 pm on Thursday, February 7, 2013
Opinions and angst are what I'm made of. I know I'm not perfect, but you obviously were able to read and comprehend my point, and there in lies the need for good teachers who are adequately compensated. Also, I would love to have you show what errors I made since you feel that I, "dropped out of the cycle."
Paul J. DiBartolo
7:19 pm on Thursday, February 7, 2013
" Please stop calling it a "fact-finding" in every other union in the world it's called arbitration."
Bad sentence, Chris. The least it would take to fix it would be a comma after "fact-finding"; that, at least, would have separated the two thoughts the sentence contained and removed it from the realm of a run-on. The other option would have been to re-write it completely and be more concise about what you were trying to say.
Again, you're correct; I got your point but you also made a point of critiquing the grammar of those who do not support the teachers.
As for my own ability to read, I attribute it more to all the books I've read rather than some individual, other than my mother. Did I get any help from teachers? Yes, but no one really sticks out as being that amazing.
Chris
11:22 am on Friday, February 8, 2013
Brevity is the soul of wit, eh? I’m sorry that your academic experience was so lack-luster. My own, uninterrupted career was filled with good teachers. As for my run-ons, that is a chronic problem of mine that earned me no credit in college. I’m surprised that you of all posters have taken offence to my comment about grammar, being that your posts are well written. After all I was referring to the people who post with no punctuation at all, use words that are unidentifiable in the English language and whose posts are so mired in jabberwocky that it is impossible to make heads or tails of their point.
Chris
11:23 am on Friday, February 8, 2013
. I’m glad that you cite books and your mother as cornerstones of your literacy. They are excellent starting points for any student. You’re illustrating my point exactly. In a world where work has taken parents almost completely out of their children’s learning experience, the responsibility has been thrust back into the laps of the teachers in full. As many posters take issue with the fact that school is only in session for 10 months out of the year and feel that teachers have a cushy job, this is not so. Teachers do a remarkable job with only 10 months to help children progress. With little or no help from home, a two month break in the summer, budget problems and often times, language barriers to stand in the way, Gloucester Township teachers are amazing at what they do. Therefore, they should be compensated as much as we can afford to. The board needs to get off of their high horse to avoid causing damage to the students, put the money where it belongs and avoid another Chicago incident.
Darren Gladden
11:56 am on Friday, February 8, 2013
ALWAYS go with heads......Smart one .....SMH
Paul J. DiBartolo
12:00 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Chris, I've looked at the compensation that our teachers are receiving and I think it's adequate. As an example, a GT Elementary School teacher with 23 years experience and a Master's degree is earning $89,600. That is for 10 months of work and is listed as such. At one time such a person got all benefits included; I'm not sure what it includes now but I'm certain that the benefit package is comparable or better than mine and I work as a professional for a major corporation.
As for the Master's degree, I'm not sure I would agree that such a degree is needed and as far as I'm concerned is already compensated for at that salary level for that job.
Bottom line, I do not see the need to compensate them any further. I took upon myself the lion's share of my children's educational requirements. That said, again, the compensation is adequate. If someone else fails to do what I did, I'm not interested in carrying their burden. Poor planning on the part of others does not constitute an emergency for me.
Darren Gladden
12:42 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
See Paul now I can understand how some people take you the wrong way ...;-)..... What happen when somethings happen to someone let's say out of the blue is it not us as a whole to help them people back to life . I say stop with all the me me stuff understand you are sounding like them just look at me .........Just care , I do
http://youtu.be/TB54dZkzZOY
Chris
12:44 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Paul, that figure is for a 23 year veteran. What about the new teachers who are just out of college and are making less than half of that? Master's Degrees are not being paid for any more. With the current standard in the state, a Master's is becoming all the more necessary. I'm glad that you were able to do for your children what you could, obviously in home schooling the since that would constitue the, "lion's share," but most cannot do so. I don't agree that parents should not be involved and I wish more were. You say that after 23 years their compensation is adequate but you fail to take into account that the purchasing of school supplies falls on the teacher much of the time and they will spend thousands of dollars a year out of their own pocket to teach. Not to mention the students who are financially strapped and teachers need to provide even the basics for them. Not everyone is in the same boat as you. My congratulations in your success, now let's give everyone the tools to be as successful.
Paul J. DiBartolo
1:44 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
The spending per student in out HS district is $16,000 per student. If teachers are spending their own money for supplies and we can't supply a good education here at those numbers then, as I've said elsewhere, it's time to scrap the system and start over. Religious schools, private schools, and charter schools are a good starting point. Our system has failed us, we can't compete on the world stage, it's time to face the music. I am not interested in throwing more good money after bad.
I will parrot the same line we hear over and over, "It's for the children." Yes, it is for the children and we owe them a good education, so let's get something that works and give up on the idea that more money is always the answer because it never is.
Paul J. DiBartolo
1:48 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Darren, you're wrong on this one. I've done more than my fair share already. I paid taxes for years without a break and nothing in the way of a rebate and never used the system I was paying for. That means I was paying to put other children through the school system while my wife and I sacrificed the possibility of additional income to stay at home and school our own kids. My kids...my responsibility.
Just Care, Darren.
Chris
2:02 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Paul, the High School district is not what is being discussed here. Out of the $16,000 per student that you say is being spent on the HIGH SCHOOL students, that entails such items like: desks, books, school lunches, etc. That has nothing to do with the teachers who are needed to instruct these students. As a parent who did not use the public school system and opted for alternative educational outlets for your children, that was your prerogative and you really have no place to say that the system has failed. For most of these students, the system is already going above and beyond for them. If you don't want to pay more taxes, without your rebate, then vote the budget down next time you vote.
Paul J. DiBartolo
2:17 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Chris, high school, elementary school, whatever...my point is that we are spending a load of money to educate these kids without much ROI. What could you do with $16,000 to educate a child for one year? And you say that the teachers are not paid out of that...you better do your homework on this. That's the per student cost in our district that is being spent. Of course the teachers are paid out of that. The point is, how much does it cost to educate one child for one year?
As for the failure of the school system; I have paid for it my whole life and I have as much right as anyone else to pass judgment on it. It didn't just fail, it's been a long time in the making. Get out and see the world, Chris, we're failing our young people. Ask over at Camden County College...75% of the HS graduates coming in have to take remedial classes. How is it working out for them and us, Chris?
The rebate I mentioned was what the districts paid to religious school students if they were unable to provide them with bus service. My point was I never asked for anything nor did I ever get anything...I just paid and paid and paid.
Chris
3:12 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Paul, what kind of return on investment are you looking for? You talk about doing the homework, and yet you know nothing of how much is spent per student in the district in question. You say that 75% of the CCC students are taking remedial courses, is that 75% entirely made up of students from Gloucester Twp.? It probably isn’t. It is a county wide institution which allows prospective students from outside the county attend classes. You speak of failing our young people, yet you refuse to help the teachers who are in a position to do good by them. I’m not hearing any propositions of solutions from you Paul, just complaints that you are taxed to high Heaven. I have been out in this world and your generation is failing the young people today. Where have the jobs all gone? It’s not for lack of qualified people coming out of college. These qualified people I speak of are the products of your, “failed system.” Yes, you paid and paid and paid, you had no choice. Please tell me what kind of return on your investment you are looking for. Were you expecting all the students to come to your house with baked goods and say, “Thank you so much! If it weren’t for you I would be out on the streets.”?
I will look into the numbers on the subject here. If you know of a way to save this failed system I’m all ears! If you have an alternative system that will not cost the taxpayers any more money, again I’m all ears!
Paul J. DiBartolo
5:33 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Hey Chris, ROI - kids that score higher than 25 out of 34 in math against their peers (other countries) and, ultimately, their competitors worldwide. I believe it would be true to say that our students used to score at the top.
So, Chris, it's not my obligation to help the teachers. They get paid for that and I have my own job to help pay their salaries, along with the fact that I raised and educated my own six children; I think I did my part.
As for the cost of educating students...I've done the homework...it's $16,000 per student in this district for high school. That entails the whole cost and it's quite high with a poor ROI.
This discussion is getting circular so, as for my views and what I've done or suggested...Here's my blog page:
http://gloucestertownship.patch.com/users/paul-j-dibartolo/blog_posts?page=1
You can look through it. There are two pieces on education; one two-parter and one five-parter. If you are serious about discussing the state of our educational system, I'm your huckleberry. If you're not willing to do the homework, as you accuse me, then let's let it rest.
See the next post for the individual links to the educational blogs I've written.
Paul J. DiBartolo
5:35 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Chris, here are the seven individual links to my blogs on education.
http://gloucestertownship.patch.com/blog_posts/the-state-of-education-part-i
http://gloucestertownship.patch.com/blog_posts/the-state-of-education-part-ii
http://gloucestertownship.patch.com/blog_posts/you-do-the-math
http://gloucestertownship.patch.com/blog_posts/education-in-america-part-i-can-we-talk-about-our-education-problems
http://gloucestertownship.patch.com/blog_posts/education-in-america-part-ii-when-is-16k-per-year-for-education-not-enough
http://gloucestertownship.patch.com/blog_posts/education-in-america-part-iii-exxonmobil-wants-to-solve-this-problem
http://gloucestertownship.patch.com/blog_posts/education-in-america-part-iv-improving-ap-test-scores-by-138-percent
http://gloucestertownship.patch.com/blog_posts/education-in-america-part-v-the-ap-tests
Chris
8:30 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Paul, I will be back after I read through all your stuff. You may have some good ideas and I'm praying over here that you do. If so, I wish you could have brought some of them to light earlier. It could have save us some serious mud-slinging.
Joe Kearney
10:33 pm on Wednesday, February 6, 2013
At the January 9th FSA Family and School Association meeting this was announced: The BOE made 2 appointments: Dr. Joanne Acerba currently principal of Mullen will be the Director of Curriculum. Orlando Mercado will be Supervisor of Student Services. This will include but not limited to residency and homeless.
l Paine
9:47 am on Thursday, February 7, 2013
Let's see the Board and our "Interim Superintendent" constantly cry poor stating they need more money, cutting staff and programs because they can't afford it, asking employees and parents for sacrifices. Yet they find room in the already bloated Administrative staff for a brand new position "Supervisor of Student Support Services" and who do they find for the position Orlando Mercado part of the township democrat machine. Let's see Ray Carr, Democrat Club President, Bill Collins, perpetual Democratic candidate who can't win an election except school board, lucky us. Another political favor forced down our throat that we have to pay for.
Meanwhile an "Interim Superintendent" with no classroom experience with District supplied truck and credit card for those lunches for friends, are they even looking for a Superintendent? A new position for one of there democratic friend's (six figures + Benefits) and we have to sacrifice. When will it end, when will this Board and Adminstration stop with the games and start to sacrifice themselves. When will people say enough!
Schu
10:31 pm on Thursday, February 7, 2013
When the voters of gt wake up and stop voting for the democrats this town might just have a chance.
Mel
7:46 pm on Thursday, February 7, 2013
Maybe this "fact-finding" is more like a discovery process? With any luck the union get the hard facts on the fical nightmare that is the district's books: the shuffling around of money with no explanation, the over-ordering of supplies that disappear, the hiring of friends and family for no show jobs, the additional perks administration members get, usage of district resources like they are the administrations personal servants, etc...
Remember the 2% cap was a way to force the bloated administrations to cut down on their waste and graft. Given the horrible state of the districts finances, do you really think Bilodau is worth $150k?
Darren Gladden
9:31 pm on Thursday, February 7, 2013
no I do not
Joe Kearney
10:03 pm on Thursday, February 7, 2013
I think Bilodau belongs in the unemployment line!
Mel
12:04 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
LT: we have a school board member who just got a job in West Deptford. No connection there... none at all. Please ignore the man behind the curtain and keep watching Honey Boo Boo please. The David Meyer Mayor Council School Board Team is counting on all of you to not pay attention while they hire their political hack friends, divert funds away from the classroom, and use your childrens school as their personal patronage pit.
LT: you and others have a great deal of information. Any thoughts on how we can all share this while protecting district employees who are watching the greatest purge since Stalin?
l Paine
12:53 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Next Board meeting Feb. 25 at Lewis School 7pm. Should be interesting contract impasse, Budget transfers, and questions not answered. As someone said earlier a Keystone Cops sideshow.
Schu
1:08 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Nobody who works for GT schools would dare to speak out against the wasteful board because they are afraid they will be transferred, fired and unemployed by the end of June. Everyone keeps their mouth shut and nobody gets hurt.
Joe Kearney
11:35 am on Sunday, February 10, 2013
I worked for Gloucester Twp Public Schools for over 9 years and was fired by the school board and John Bilodau for not calling out sick while I was in a COMA! I have the paper work to back it up. That whole system over there is messed up they fire sick people all the time. They have a special hack doctor they send you too in Marlton, I was cleared to go back to work by University of Penn doctors to go back to work. They sent me to some quack named Tim Pinsky http://bestmedconsultants.net. They do what ever they want when they want. There are so many things gone on over there it would amaze most of you.
l Paine
3:31 pm on Sunday, February 10, 2013
There is very isn't anything this Board or Bilodeau can do that would suprise me. Wait I'm wrong there is one thing that would suprise me, THE RIGHT THING!
BrianT
11:05 am on Friday, February 15, 2013
Fact finding means the union is looking at other districts around the state to argue a comparable settlement. Can't argue with that. GT has far fewer administrators than most districts this size (even when they were fully staffed) and pays them far less. All of the administrators who left in the past year are making more money than they did in GT. The BOE is beyond cheap compared to other districts locally and despite property taxes, NJ has similar per pupil spending to PA where property taxes are lower.
It's not the teachers' fault your taxes are high - it's the tax system.
Didjaknow
11:43 am on Friday, February 15, 2013
I agree, the tax system puts the local taxpayers at odds with their local school system and that is just a bad system. As far as the people that left GT to other positions- people don't leave tenured positions for a few extra bucks. If you have any teachers in your famly, they will tell you that. They ran from a superintendent that has no clue and a school board that is out of control. Our kids are suffering for it.
BrianT
3:20 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013
Oh absolutely, they did! I was just noting that GT salaries are lower than the average rate and that people who leave generally do better elsewhere. Too many people crying here about how much everyone makes.
Head
12:25 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013
But. BrianT, virtually every administrator in the GT district is excessive cost to taxpayers, in my opinion, because of the redundancy that exists by having separate administrations for our high schools and our K-8 schools.
BrianT
3:22 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013
Agreed - the current administrations can't make that merger happen though. There are two school boards, too. Talk to them about making that happen. Even still - if the two merged, you'd still need a lot of administrators to make things work. Just because people don't know what administrators do all day, doesn't mean they aren't needed.
Head
12:38 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013
Fact Finding is more than a union thing.
A Fact Finder is a supposedly neutral third party hired by the state. He takes arguments that are presented to him from both the union and the administration, and makes objective recommendations.
Problems with this: 1)The recommendations are not binding; 2)Due to Christie cutbacks, there are only two Fact Finders in the state. With hundreds of NJ districts with expired teacher contracts, it takes months and months from when arguments are presented until recommendations are given.
This situation, along with the legal restraints against teacher strikes, gives school boards all the leverage, and zero incentive to bargain in good faith to settle contracts.
Roger Delgado
4:55 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013
Does anyone have more information about the after school tutoring program that as abruptly ended this week because of budget misappropriations? My child came from school and told me the SNAP program ended becasue "they ran out of money". This was confirmed by district employees.
How can a program like this simply run out of money when they have a fixed set of children for a fixed period of time? How many other programs have been cut because of the district administration's incompetience.
As a township resident I am concerned we can't manage a simple fiscal ledger. As a parent I am outraged that any of my children come home saying the school ran out of money to help him.
Where are the school boards priorities? Where did the money for this program go? Looking at the last meeting's minutes hundreds of thousands of dollars were moved around into "Misc Admin" accounts. What are these?
Paul J. DiBartolo
7:52 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013
The school system here is officially a disaster. The WOW Science Camp is being offered for children ages 5 through 14 for 8 weeks in the summer for $3167. So, we pay outrageous taxes to have our kids educated and then are told that if we really want our kids to succeed we probably should think about shelling out over three grand so they can learn what they didn't learn all year in school.
Stache's Minion
8:02 pm on Friday, February 15, 2013
Yes Paul our town is a mess. We steal from our children then assassinate those who try to expose it. Don't look behind the curtain folks, we can't have that. The Great Stache will not be pleased.
l Paine
4:28 pm on Thursday, February 21, 2013
Money is constantly moved from account to account almost every month. Makes you wonder how they have that much extra money? Is the Budget real or are accounts padded so that Administration and the Board can buy and do the things THEY want? The Fiscal year for the District ends June 30 pay attention to April and May Board minutes for Budget Transfers and the end of the year buying spree. Last year they moved enough around at the end of the year to buy a Backhoe. You would think an item that exspensive would have been budgeted for. Kind of hard to believe Bilodeau and the Board crying that they need more money when you watch the Budget shell game.
M
12:23 am on Sunday, February 24, 2013
GT residents need to keep pushing the board to give them answers. Parents need to pay attention and ask questions. Where is your money really going? Do you see it in your child's school? So many comments blame the teachers and feel they don't deserve anything, but these teachers are educating and caring for your children. They don't even have the resources most other districts have in the classroom. Many comments are so untrue.They don't have summers off. They have July and August off, and that's if they're not working another job. August is spent in the classroom preparing for the upcoming school year. So, maybe they have off a month...that's 4 weeks vacation...plus holidays during the year, UNPAID! They also work past their contracted 6.5 hrs. It takes more than a 1/2 hr prep time to plan, prepare, grade, call parents, write notes, and take care of anything else that involves students and the school day.The district's money mess isn't the teachers' fault.
M
12:26 am on Sunday, February 24, 2013
For those who bash teachers, check this out...
Teachers’ hefty salaries are driving up taxes, and they only work10 months a year. It’s time we put things in perspective and pay them for what they do,babysit.We can get that for less than minimum wage.That’s right. Let’s give them $3 an hour and only the hours they worked; not any of that silly planning time, or any time they spend before or after school.That would be $19.50 a day (7:45 to 3:00 PM with 45 min. off for lunch and plan– that equals 6 1/2 hours).Each parent should pay $19.50 a day for these teachers to baby-sit their children. Now how many students do they teach in a day,maybe 30? So that’s $19.50 x 30 = $585.00 a day.However, remember they only work 180 days a year.I am not going to pay them for any vacations.LET’S SEE…That’s $585 X 180= $105,300 per year. (Hold on. My calculator needs new batteries.) What about those special education teachers and the ones with master’s degrees? Well, we could pay them minimum wage ($7.75), and just to be fair, round it off to $8.00 an hour.That would be $8 X 6 1/2 hours X 30 children X 180 days = $280,800 per year.Wait a minute — there’s something wrong here.There sure is!The average teacher’s salary (nationwide) is $50,000. $50,000/180 days = $277.77/per day/30 students=$9.25/6.5 hours = $1.42 per hour per student– a very inexpensive baby-sitter and they even EDUCATE your kids!)
WHAT A DEAL!
l Paine
12:35 am on Sunday, February 24, 2013
Just looked at Monday's School Board meeting agenda and guess what? Suprise, suprise the shell game continues, more budget transfers. Keep moving the money around until people lose track, and we still get to look forward to the May, June buying spree.Hard to believe they have all this extra money in these accounts that they can move money around every month. Wonder what other surprises Bilodeau and the Board have that's not on the agenda. You have to know they wil try to slip something by most. Time to bring this Board and Bilodeau into the light.
l Paine
1:02 am on Wednesday, February 27, 2013
Do you think the Board and Bilodeau are finally willing to start doing the right thing?